Status recorded 2026-02-15 — see the reasonSHORT · 1H

HV Squeeze

Same Bollinger Band squeeze detection as BB Squeeze with a lighter filter set (candle color, 1.5x volume). Off the curated roster since 2026-02-15 — it covers 85.9% of BB Squeeze's setups and fires 5.8x as often, with no additional edge.

Read the dated measurement, settings and limits below. A historical backtest does not establish future or live execution performance.


Added: 2026-01-15Research status recorded: 2026-02-15Write-up stats measured: 2026-01 Old data — Measured 2026-01 — more than 6 months agoMeasurement conditions unknownCard re-measured (top 10 coins · 1H · 2026-11-20)577 Coins Tested
Win Rate · as published (577 coins · 1H · 2026-01)Win Rate — Percentage of profitable trades. Above 50% with good risk/reward is solid.

58.1%

break-even 49.4% at its realized average win/loss

re-measured (top 10 coins · 1H · 2026-11-20): 50.65%

Percentage of trades that were profitable

Profit Factor · as published (577 coins · 1H · 2026-01)Profit Factor — Total gains divided by total losses. Above 1.5 is strong, above 2.0 is excellent.

1.42

re-measured (top 10 coins · 1H · 2026-11-20): 0.98

Gross profit / gross loss ratio

as published (577 coins · 1H · 2026-01)

Marks next to a metric: ~ = borderline (PF between break-even and 1.5; win rate ≤5 pts above break-even, or 50–55% if none shown) · ! = below the bar, or the strategy's research status (dated on its page) is below the bar — that dated record outranks this number. No mark = clears it and its research status is not below the bar.

Status recorded 2026-02-15 — see the reason

No live tracking — measured, not guaranteed

Card re-measured: 2026-11-20 · 2,780 trades analyzed

Overview


HV Squeeze uses the same Bollinger Band squeeze detection as BB Squeeze — the bands are computed and used directly. What differs is the filter set: a lower volume threshold (1.5x vs 2.0x) and a candle-color direction filter instead of the EMA trend.

The hypothesis: a lighter filter set (previous candle color instead of EMA trend, a lower volume bar) might catch expansions that BB Squeeze’s stricter filters miss.

How It Works


  1. Detect Squeeze — BB (20, 2σ) width drops below 0.8x its own 20-period moving average; a squeeze within the last 10 candles qualifies
  2. Wait for Expansion — BB width increasing (current > previous)
  3. Volume Filter — previous candle’s volume >= 1.5x its 20-period average
  4. Direction Filter — previous candle color (bearish candle + close below BB mid = SHORT)
  5. Enter Short — Same risk management (SL 10%, TP 8%, 48h max hold)

Test Results


MetricHV SqueezeBB SqueezeDifference
Win Rate58.1%68.6%-10.5%p
Profit Factor1.422.22-36%
Signals fired12,2402,1105.8x
HV signals BB also fires14.8%——
BB signals HV also fires85.9%——

Corrected 2026-09-21. These two rows used to read “Signal Overlap 85% / Unique Signals 15%”, which had the direction backwards. Re-measured on the top-10 market-cap coins, 1h candles, 2023-12-10 → 2026-07-12: only 14.8% of HV’s signals land on a bar where BB Squeeze also fires the same way, while 85.9% of BB Squeeze’s signals are ones HV also fires. HV is not a subset of BB Squeeze — it is a looser superset that fires 5.8x as often. No tolerance window or direction rule reaches 85% on the HV side (±24 bars, direction ignored: 43.2% at most). Method and per-coin numbers: backend/research/20260921/hv_bb_signal_overlap.json (reproduce with the .py beside it).

The old line “the 15% of unique HV signals had a win rate of 47%” is withdrawn — its population was the inverted 15%. Now measured (2026-09-22, same scope and the card’s own config — hv-squeeze registry defaults, SL 10% / TP 6%, futures costs): the real HV-only set — bars where BB Squeeze does not fire the same way — wins 50.18% across 2196 trades with a profit factor of 0.91. The 218 trades that do overlap BB Squeeze win 55.96% with a profit factor of 1.35.

So HV’s extra signals do not add edge, they dilute it: the 9% of trades BB Squeeze also catches carry the profit factor above 1, and the rest drag it below. That is a different reason from “redundant” — and it is the reason the card was taken off the roster. Method, per-coin numbers and the sanity check against the card: backend/research/20260922/hv_only_subset_performance.json (reproduce with the .py beside it). Trades were labelled, not filtered — the engine holds one position per coin, so re-running with overlapping signals removed would create trades the card never had.

Why It Was Taken Off the Roster


  1. A looser superset, not a subset — HV covers 85.9% of BB Squeeze’s setups and fires 5.8x as often. The redundancy is real, but it runs the other way: almost everything BB catches, HV also catches, plus a large tail of its own.
  2. Check the latest measurement — see the HV Squeeze live card on the strategies page for current metrics and their measurement scope. The table above is a historical measurement, not the current card’s results.
  3. Complexity without edge — Adding a second volatility measure doubles code maintenance but adds zero PnL
  4. Archived BB Squeeze comparison — the cited record covers 2+ years, 535 coins and 2,898 trades. Its exact measurement date is not specified in this comparison; those figures do not establish current performance.

Lesson Learned


Not every variation of a working idea is an improvement. Sometimes the first implementation is also the best one.

HV Squeeze taught us that indicator substitution is not optimization. The edge in BB Squeeze comes from the squeeze-to-expansion transition pattern, not from the specific method of measuring volatility. BB and HV measure the same underlying phenomenon — price compression — just with different math.

Potential Revisit


HV Squeeze could become relevant if:

  • BB Squeeze edge degrades below profitability threshold
  • Market microstructure changes (e.g., new exchange mechanisms alter BB behavior)
  • Combining both as an ensemble shows uncorrelated alpha on HV’s own signals — the 85.2% that BB Squeeze does not fire (the old wording said 15%; see the 2026-09-21 correction above)

The dated overlap and HV-only measurements above describe the observed trade sets; they do not establish future superiority of either signal.

Status: off the curated roster since 2026-02-15


Scope note (corrected 2026-09-25): the numbers on this page (WR 58.1%, PF 1.42) come from the January 2026 Binance-era test on 577 coins. An earlier version of this note said coins: 235 was the OKX universe of a 2026-04-10 re-measure — there was no such re-measure: 235 was the OKX roster count copied in on 2026-05-02. Today’s coin list is on /coins.

Not actively traded. Last tested: January 2026 on 577 coins with 2+ years of data.

Explore more strategies and their research results.