Donchian Breakout

Turtle Trading 20-period channel breakout. SHORT showed PF 1.27 (bull) / 1.06 (bear) in the original 2026-04 backtest, but failed a fresh out-of-sample regime-robustness re-test on 2026-06-28 (bear-beta artifact). Backtest is reproducible; the live directional edge is not.

Current-data re-measure: ◐ Conditional (top 10 coins · 1H · 2026-10-06)

Retired: 2026-07-12


Added: 2026-01-01Doc updated: 2026-04-01 (measurement date unknown)Measurement conditions unknownCard re-measured (top 10 coins · 1H · 2026-10-06)
Profit Factor · as published 2026-04-01Profit Factor — Total gains divided by total losses. Above 1.5 is strong, above 2.0 is excellent.

1.27

re-measured (top 10 coins · 1H · 2026-10-06): 0.92

Gross profit / gross loss ratio

updated 2026-04-01

Marks next to a metric: ~ = borderline (PF between break-even and 1.5; win rate ≤5 pts above break-even, or 50–55% if none shown) · ! = below the bar, or the strategy is already retired or shelved — a closed verdict outranks its number. No mark = clears it and is still standing.

RETIRED

Wins only under specific regimes or windows in our measurements — the card's bull/bear PF row shows the regime side; strategies that win both windows were still killed by half-year walk-forward instability. A past condition profile, not a recommendation — conditions earn trust only by surviving forward.

Card re-measured: 2026-10-06 · 3,205 trades analyzed

Overview


The Donchian channel goes back to Richard Donchian, the futures pioneer who popularized N-period breakout rules decades before they became famous — the 1980s Turtle Trading experiment taught Richard Dennis’s novices a Donchian-style breakout, not the other way around. It enters when price breaks above or below the 20-period channel — a signal that a new trend may be establishing.

In the original 2026-04 backtest the SHORT side appeared profitable in both bull and bear samples. A fresh out-of-sample re-test on 2026-06-28 — same product engine, 18-cell sweep with a 5-axis adversarial kill — found this regime-robustness did not hold: the apparent edge was a bear-beta artifact, not a directional skill that survives unseen data. The backtest numbers below are reproducible, but we no longer present this as a live directional edge.

How It Works


  1. Channel calculation — highest high and lowest low over the past 20 bars (look-ahead safe: uses bars up to but not including the signal bar)
  2. LONG signal — current close breaks above the 20-bar high (upward momentum)
  3. SHORT signal — current close breaks below the 20-bar low (downward momentum)

The indicator is two-sided; this preset is not. Steps 2 and 3 describe what a Donchian channel can signal. What we curated, measured and publish here is the short leg only — the engine’s default for donchian-breakout is short, and every number below comes from short-side runs. (Corrected 2026-09-06: this file’s frontmatter used to say direction: both, which disagreed with the preset, the backend registry and its own results section.)

  1. Entry — at the open of the next bar after the break
  2. Exit — TP 10% / SL 8%

Why It Works (Thesis)


The 20-period channel captures significant price movements that break out of consolidation zones. When price violates a multi-week high or low, it often signals the beginning of a directional move rather than random noise. The SHORT side looked stronger in the original sample because crypto assets frequently exhibit sharp, fast sell-offs — channel breaks to the downside tend to have stronger follow-through than upside breaks in a market prone to liquidation cascades.

That thesis is plausible, but the fresh OOS re-test (2026-06-28) showed the measured SHORT profit was driven by a falling market (short positions making money simply because price went down) rather than by a regime-independent breakout edge. Strip out that bear-beta and the standalone edge does not survive — so treat the thesis as unconfirmed.

Results


Market regimeProfit factor (SHORT)
Bull market1.27
Bear market1.06

These are the original 2026-04 backtest numbers and are reproducible. They are not evidence of robustness: a fresh out-of-sample re-test on 2026-06-28 failed regime-robustness, attributing the result to bear-beta rather than a regime-independent edge.

Default Parameters


ParameterValue
Channel period20 bars
Exit period10 bars
Stop loss8%
Take profit10%

Caveats


  • Failed fresh out-of-sample regime-robustness (2026-06-28). The earlier “profitable in both regimes” claim did not survive re-testing — the edge read as bear-beta, not a directional skill. Status downgraded from verified to testing for this reason, then subsequently retired. Two owners, on purpose: this file’s frontmatter status owns the membership (verified / testing / killed / shelved — the fact that it was killed stays), and src/config/simulator-presets.ts owns the verdict (verdict3) that the strategy badges and the public API read.
  • Lower profit factor in bear markets (1.06) — thin edge that would likely disappear under transaction costs in high-frequency trading.
  • LONG direction not separately validated.
  • Classic trend-following: suffers during choppy, range-bound markets.
  • Not live-tracked on OKX. Backtest only — “verified” here means the backtest is reproducible, not that the live directional edge is confirmed.

Explore more strategies and their research results.